Have you ever looked at the blinking light on your smoke detector at home wondering, how does that thing work, and why does it always go off when I’m cooking? For most home smoke detectors there are two basic types, photoelectric and ionization. What is the difference between the two? Why is one preferred over the other in some regions? I heard that the ionization smoke detectors have some radioactive material in them. What is worse, the fire or being constantly bombarded by the radiation from my smoke detector?
Photoelectric smoke detectors operate on a simple principle of detecting smoke particles in a small chamber. Infrared LEDs shine light into the chamber and is detected by a photo-detector. If smoke particles enter the chamber, some of the infrared light is scattered and reflected to the photo-detector. After a specified amount of light is detected (relative to a specified amount of smoke particles), then an alarm is sounded.
Ionization smoke detectors have a small amount of americium-241 (about 0.2mg or 1/5000 of a gram) that ionize the air between two plates causing free electrons to move through an electric field. If smoke is introduced, then the number of free electrons is reduced. This causes a change in the voltage across the plates and then an alarm is sounded.
So what is the difference between the two types? Essentially there isn’t much difference because both types of smoke detectors have to meet the same standards for smoke detection. However photoelectric detectors are typically better at detecting smoldering fires with more particles vs. ionization detectors which are better at gas type fires. In this case, ionization detectors would sound an alarm with my cooking before the photoelectric detector.
Are you in danger of radiation poison from ionization smoke detectors? No, you have more chance of getting radiation poisoning from standing outside in the sun. The small amount of material radiates such a small amount that there is no danger for close exposure to the smoke detector. However, some regions are concerned about the disposal of this material after the smoke detector has reached its end of life. That is why Europe typically favors photoelectric smoke detectors and the Americas and Asia typically favor ionization smoke detectors.
Related Links

